Elvis Costello and the Attractions: The Very Best of (1994)

I've written a lot about how to make a perfect best-of compilation. This one ticks off every box on the checklist. Chronological order? Check. No new songs? Check. No remixes or live versions? Check. It also helps to have had as many amazing singles as Elvis did from 1977 to 1986. There's not a bad song in the bunch, nor a major omission.

Counting Crows: August and Everything After (1994)

In the great pantheon of enjoyably depressive albums, August and Everything After holds an elevated place. While the band works up track after track of amiable country rock, Adam Duritz layers on a melancholy vibe, even on the songs that aren't especially lyrically sad.

As such, this album has been a trusted companion through many a lonely night, especially when I first arrived at college and became instantly nostalgic for the life I'd so eagerly left behind.

And, of course, when you end your album with your best song (A Murder of One), you've definitely done something right.

Marshall Crenshaw: Marshall Crenshaw (1982)

The public radio station in my hometown used to host an annual record sale. It was boxes and boxes full of vinyl for $1 each. I went each year with my dad and step-mom and bought whatever they recommended. It was a great way to get a crash course in pop music history. Their recommendations hit way more than they missed, in fact my first exposure to several albums on this list came from those sales, including this one. As a Beatles-obsessed kid, how could I not love the throwback pop bliss of There She Goes Again, Cynical Girl, and Someday, Someway? It's important to note that these songs and performances stand on their own; they're not simple pastiche. They really take the pop sensibilities of Buddy Holly and The Beatles and put them through a (then) modern lens.

Crowded House: Recurring Dream: The Very Best of... (1996)

Recurring Dream, a 1996 compilation (and then-swan song before the band was reconstituted in 2007), was my first exposure to Crowded House. I've since bought all of their albums, but my opinion hasn't changed: This is their best record. Going non-chronologically, the band share four tracks from each of their first four albums, along with three new songs recorded for an album that was not-to-be.

The new songs fit well, there's no glaring omissions, and the 19 tracks offer an embarrassment of melodic beauty, especially Weather With You, Fall At Your Feet, Don't Dream It's Over, I Feel Possessed, and Better Be Home Soon.

Death Cab for Cutie: Narrow Stairs (2008)

When Narrow Stairs came out, I made a conscious choice not to buy it. I was in the midst of changing my purchasing habits, and that meant new albums by artists I liked didn't automatically get a buy. They had to earn it. After seeing Death Cab live on the tour for this album, Narrow Stairs earned it. Not only did it earn its keep, it slowly became my favorite of their albums. A sense of dread hangs over all of the songs, not only lyrically but musically as well. But it's that kind of dread you enjoy because it's not actually happening to you. Instead, you admire how the artist was able to express themselves so well, whether through once-removed distance (Cath...) or startlingly personal confessions (I Will Possess Your Heart).

The Decemberists: The King is Dead (2011)

Just a beautifully consistent folk country pop album.  Like most of my recent favorites I found myself returning to the album again and again after the initial listening period had passed, until eventually the it felt indispensable. Every single song is a mini-masterpiece, but June Hymn creates an inexplicable welling of emotion in me every time.

John Denver and the Muppets: A Christmas Together (1979)

By all accounts I was a Muppet-obsessed kid from age 2 on, and so for as long as I can remember A Christmas Together has been my favorite Christmas album. If you think about it, music has always been an integral part of the appeal of the Muppets, from Sesame Street to The Muppet Show to the various Muppet movies. And they're not always silly songs. In fact, it's pretty amazing the way the Muppet performers (Jim Henson, Frank Oz, Jerry Nelson, Richard Hunt, and Dave Goelz) can elicit genuine emotion while singing in a weird voices.

A Christmas Together illustrates that perfectly. The fun, witty side of the Muppets is on display in takes on The Twelve Days of Christmas, Christmas is Coming, We Wish You A Merry Christmas ("Piggy pudding?!"), and a cover of The Beach Boys' Little Saint Nick by Dr. Teeth and his Electric Mayhem. But there's genuine depth and gravitas on the album as well. Of course Denver, in supreme warm, gentle, sentimental mode, plays a big part in that. For evidence, listen to the melancholy take on Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas, a piano-driven duet between Rowlf (Henson) and Denver, or the harmony-laden The Peace Carol. Two show-stoppers drive home the majesty of Christmas: Robin (Nelson) and Denver's version of When the River Meets the Sea (a song originally featured in the Henson production Emmet Otter's Jug Band Christmas) and Silent Night, Holy Night, which begins in the original German, and also features Denver telling the story behind the composition of the song.

Depeche Mode: The Singles 81>85 (1985)

I love Violator as much as the next guy, but to me Depeche Mode were at their best early on. The exquisite moodiness is there (especially on standouts Blasphemous Rumours and Shake the Disease), but the inclusion of songs by Vince Clarke (who left for Yaz, then Erasure) means this collection has a welcome levity that's missing from their later work.

Neil Diamond: The Jazz Singer (1980)

My mom was a huge Neil Diamond freak, and being that this is the album that was out around the time I first gained sentience, it's the one that sticks with me.

The movie is really kinda goofy, but the album? Honestly, I believe everything that makes Diamond great is here: The '60s-style pop of You Baby and Hey Louise, the earnest balladeering of Love on the Rocks and Hello Again, and the bombast of America and Amazed and Confused.

Dire Straits: Making Movies (1980)

Honestly I'm not much of a Dire Straits or Mark Knopfler fan, but this specific album manages to not only transcend my blasé, but turn it temporarily to adoration. Strong lyrical storytelling married with cinematic, slow-burn melodies are an irresistable combination on songs like Tunnel of Love, Romeo and Juliet, and Skateaway.

Other songs (Expresso Love, Solid Rock) bring to mind a more laid-back Springsteen, perhaps because E-Streeter Roy Bittan played keys on the album.

Pete Droge and the Sinners: Find a Door (1996)

I somehow missed out on Pete Droge's 1994 hit (If You Don't Love Me ) I'll Kill Myself, but a glowing review of his second album, Find a Door, sold me. Right after buying it, I left for a summer road trip and Find a Door turned out to be a perfect travelling record. It's full of likeable mid-tempo alternative country that strikes the right balance between gravitas and humor. It's also the rare record where the rockers (Brakeman, That Ain't Right) and the slow songs (Out With You, Sooner Than Later) are equally arresting. I also love how the final song, Lord Is Busy, ends with Droge putting down his guitar, walking out of the room, and saying, "Thanks for buyin' my record!".

Bob Dylan: Blood on the Tracks (1975)

I have a contentious relationship with Robert Zimmerman; it all started when we were riding the rails together and he said the pattern of the stitches on my sealskin saddle shoes were "clearly maleficent".

Actually, I can't shake most of the usual knocks against Dylan, namely that he's often inscrutable, that his voice leaves too much to be desired, and that his songs are usually better performed by others.

But even I can't deny the sad, beautiful brilliance of Blood on the Tracks. I guess Dylan has denied the oft-assumed interpretation that these songs were about his own personal turmoil and has instead purported to have been inspired by Anton Chekhov's short stories. Since I'm fascinated by art that comes from personal pain and tumult, I hope he's lying. Given Dylan's relationship with "truth" I'm probably safe.

Everclear: Songs From An American Movie Vol. One: Learning How To Smile (2000)

Songs From An American Movie Vol. One takes Art Alexakis' confessional writing style (see: Father of Mine) to its logical limit. The album vacillates between rehashing the past (both recent and distant) and trying to reconcile the present, between obsessing over pain and celebrating life's amazing little moments. It's a bit too earnest in places, but when it emotionally connects, as it does often for me, it's pretty powerful.

True story: Some friends and I once walked right past the members of Everclear on a random residential street in Uptown Minneapolis. Why were they there? Where were they going? We might never know.

Ben Folds: Songs for Silverman (2005)

Read a review here.

I hold a soft spot for all of Ben Folds' work, but Songs for Silverman has a special place. Maybe it's because I love Folds songs when he's doing the lush jazzy balladry thing, which he does A LOT on this record. Maybe it's because I can identify so well with the handful of songs that document f-ed up relationships (and especially so at the time of this album's release). Or maybe it's because "Weird Al" does background vocals on Time.

But probably it's just that every single song is good. Like, really really good.

Marvin Gaye: What's Going On (1971)

In the early '70s, Motown loosed the reigns on some of their most talented and successful artists and were rewarded with Stevie Wonder's Talking Book, and Marvin Gaye's What's Going On. Ironically, Gaye's artistic freedom from hit singles produced a cohesive album with three of his greatest singles: Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology), Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler), and the title track. It's striking that the questions Marvin raises about religion, race, war, the economy, and the environment are still so pertinent today.

The Get-Up Kids: Red Letter Day EP (1999)

This EP was released as a warm-up to The Get-Up Kids' second album Something to Write Home About, and has the titular song in common with that record. It's not unusual for a band to put out a preview release to build anticipation, usually featuring a song from the upcoming album along with a live version or demo or some tossed-off b-sides. But this isn't that. For one, Red Letter Day isn't even the lead track first song (that'd be the soaring One Year Later). And the three accompanying songs (Forgive and Forget, Anne Arbour, and Mass Pike) are all quite album-worthy. That's probably why I ended up loving this more than the album it was supposed to be psyching me up for.

Sammy Hagar: Marching to Mars (1997)

Read a review here.

Sammy Hagar is not known for his lyrical depth, despite what he might think. Even his best Van Halen ballads were dad cliches dressed up with power chords. But on his first post-Van Halen album he chronicles the stages of his break-up grief and in the process produces something profound.

Little White Lie, Salvation on Sand Hill, and Would You Do It For Free move from denial to anger. There's a bit of bargaining in On the Other Hand, and depression sets in on Leaving the Warmth of the Womb. But finally we come to acceptance with Both Sides Now and Amnesty is Granted. Now whether any of this was fully intended, I don't know, but it still rings true all these years later.

Vince Guaraldi Trio: Oh Good Grief! (1968)

In 1968, Guaraldi re-recorded some of his work for the Peanuts cartoon specials using an electric harpsichord in addition to his usual piano. The result is a slightly funkier version of those familiar tunes. I didn't know anything about the re-recording when I first bought Oh Good Grief!, so these are actually my favorite versions. Plus, how could you not love that cover drawing with Snoopy sporting Guaraldi's trademark glasses and mustache? If you want the originals, seek out A Boy Named Charlie Brown and A Charlie Brown Christmas, both of which are very worth owning.

Harlem Shakes: Technicolor Health (2009)

Harlem Shakes broke up just a few months after releasing this full-length debut. The album met with poor reviews, especially from Pitchfork, who mostly railed on the band for their optimistic outlook (?!). Ironically, that (and sluggish sales) caused the band to pack it in.

They left us with Technicolor Health, a crackerjack album full of kitchen sink indie power pop sung in a nerdy voice. I bought it back when it came out, and my admiration has steadily grown. Favorites include Strict Game, Sunlight, Unhurried Hearts (Passaic Pastoral), and Nothing But Change, Pt. 2.

The Honeydogs: Amygdala (2006)

Read a review here.

I have an admitted bias in favor of bands from the Twin Cities. There's no real logic to it, but I'll give a local act more benefit of the doubt than one from another city. That said, I like to think that Amygdala would mean just as much to me if I had never set foot in Minneapolis or Saint Paul. Melodically rich and lyrically deep, it's the kind of record you can return to endlessly.

Michael Jackson: Thriller (1982)

Anyone who was alive and at least semi-conscious in 1983 has to have been affected by this record. I'd venture to say that there'll never be another album that captivates so many people so absolutely. I was six years old and I vividly remember watching the Thriller video and listening to a Beat It 45 over and over at summer daycare.

Looking at it now, the audaciousness and oddity of the album are striking. Of course that seems perfectly fitting with the knowledge of all the Jackson-related strangeness that came about in its wake (Neverland Ranch, Bubbles the Chimp, hyperbaric chambers, etc.). But when Thriller was first released Michael was just a former child star who was trying to duplicate or better the solo success of Off the Wall. And here he's got guests like Paul McCartney, Eddie Van Halen, and Vincent Price, bold stylistic shifts, and lyrics like "Still they hate you / You're a vegetable."

The Jayhawks: Tomorrow the Green Grass (1995)

My paternal grandfather bought this for me in a Venture department store, along with Blues Traveler's four. Only one is still in my CD collection, let alone a favorite. I didn't know one day I'd move to Minneapolis, and I wasn't especially a fan of country at the time, so I don't even know why I wanted it. But its sweet-sounding wistfulness connected right away, and continues to do so even after all these years. Favorites include Blue, I'd Run Away, and Bad Time (a Grand Funk Railroad cover?!).



Jay-Z: MTV Unplugged (2001)

Jay-Z's greatest hits (up to that point) performed live with The Roots providing back-up? If for some reason the kids one day don't understand just how talented and charismatic Hova really was, this is Exhibit A.

Jellyfish: Bellybutton (1990)

This record is a melodic buffet that tastes better with each return trip. Reading about its painstaking construction in Craig Dorfman's Brighter Day: A Jellyfish Story somehow made the album seem more magical instead of less.

Jimmy Eat World: Clarity (1999)

There was a time when I thought this album brought me luck. It always seemed to be on the stereo when I received good news. Maybe there was some mystical connection, or maybe I just played it all the damn time!

Jimmy Eat World: Bleed American (2001)

My then-roommate Nick and I "discovered" Jimmy Eat World in 1997 via a sampler I found at our college radio station (I was the public relations guy, which meant I had almost unlimited access to our library of promo CDs) and the song Opener. We quickly tracked down their Capitol debut, Static Prevails, and went to see them perform in Champaign, Illinois.

Later, Clarity hit us like a revelation from God himself, but I was in no way prepared for their pop breakthrough, Bleed American (later changed to simply Jimmy Eat World to avoid 9-11 controversy). It wasn't just the fact that they had a hit on the radio and a video on MTV with The Middle; it was that the album was in many ways even better than Clarity. The hard-hitting title track, A Praise Chorus, If You Don't, Don't, Sweetness, Hear You Me, and Authority Song were just so. damn. good.

Usually fans feel a bit jilted when one of their faves becomes massively popular. I just felt proud.

Jimmy Eat World: Chase This Light (2007)

Generally speaking, this is the Jimmy Eat World album that gets derided the most. Some fans decry the shiny production (partially by Garbage man Butch Vig), others the poppy bent of the songwriting. They're not factually wrong; Chase This Light is easily Jimmy's most burnished and catchy album. I suppose that's why they call them opinions, but those are the exact reasons I love it so much.

I don't want Jimmy Eat World to sound like a handclappy power pop band all the time, but for one album? Awesome. My faves include the title track, Let It Happen, Always Be, and Here It Goes.